image of makeup brushes with article on how to choose the best makeup brushes

CHOOSING BETTER MAKEUP BRUSHES

How to Choose Better Makeup Brushes

Let’s be honest—makeup gets all the attention, but it’s your tools that make the magic happen. A flawless finish isn’t just about what’s in your makeup bag—it’s about what’s in your hand. And when it comes to choosing the right makeup brushes, it can feel a little overwhelming.

If you've ever bought a brush that shed like a cat or fell apart after a few uses, I feel your pain. That’s why I’m here to share what actually matters when selecting high-quality, cruelty-free brushes—and why I only design with engineered synthetic nylon bristles at Otis Batterbee.

Why Your Brushes Matter

Even the best foundation or eyeshadow can look patchy if you’re applying it with a poor-quality brush. But here's the good news: choosing the right brush doesn't mean choosing the most expensive one—it means understanding the essentials of great design and performance.

Start with the Build: Handle & Ferrule

Let’s begin with what holds your brush together.

  • The Handle: I recommend a solid wooden handle—it offers weight, balance, and durability. No flimsy plastic here.

  • The Ferrule: That’s the metal piece that connects the bristles to the handle. It’s one of the most important parts of the brush, as it’s where the bristles are glued and crimped securely into place. A loose or poorly made ferrule can cause shedding or even cause the brush to fall apart over time. Avoid shiny, lightweight ferrules—these are often made from cheaper materials, which can loosen, dent, or corrode with use.

At Otis Batterbee, our brushes are crafted with sustainably sourced wood handles and black ferrules—designed for longevity, performance, and a beautiful feel in-hand.

Why I Only Use Synthetic Nylon Bristles

All Otis Batterbee brushes are made with vegan synthetic nylon bristles—and there are good reasons behind that choice.

Here's why nylon bristles are the new standard in brush performance:

  • 100% Vegan & Cruelty-Free
    Let’s be honest—the idea of using animal hair on your face is outdated and, frankly, a little gross. That’s why I use only vegan synthetic nylon bristles in every Otis Batterbee brush.

  • Soft Yet Structured
    Nylon bristles are silky to the touch but hold their shape beautifully, giving you both control and a smooth finish.

  • Ideal for Creams, Liquids, and Powders
    Unlike animal hair, nylon bristles don’t absorb product—so your foundation, blush, and highlighter stay where they belong: on your face, not trapped in a brush.

  • Hypoallergenic
    No animal hair means less risk of irritation—just smooth, skin-friendly application that’s safe even for sensitive skin.

  • Effortless to Clean & Long-Lasting
    Nylon resists staining and holds up to frequent washing, which means your brushes stay hygienic and high-performing longer.

What Makes a Brush Worth It

Here’s how to spot a brush that’s made to perform:

  • Minimal Shedding: Gently tug the bristles. A few loose hairs are okay—but anything more? Walk away.

  • Symmetrical Shape: Quality brushes are hand-shaped and hold a consistent, even silhouette.

  • Responsive Bristles: They should be soft, flexible, and spring back to shape with ease.

  • Tight Ferrule: Give it a twist—if anything wobbles, it’s a no-go.

  • Comfortable Grip: A good brush feels like an extension of your hand.

My Essential Nylon Makeup Brush Picks

If you're just starting your collection—or upgrading what you’ve got—here are my go-to tools from the Otis Batterbee range, all featuring engineered nylon bristles:

Final Thoughts

Choosing better makeup brushes doesn’t have to be complicated. When you know what to look for—solid materials, high-performance bristles, and thoughtful design—you can invest with confidence. And with synthetic nylon bristles, you’re not only getting pro-level performance, you’re making a kinder, cleaner choice for your skin and the planet.

Explore the Otis Batterbee brush collection and experience what it means to use tools that work with your products—not against them.

Otis x 

Back to OTIS'S JOURNAL

Discover More

View all